Cheaper options than Graphene?
from Postmortal_Pop@lemmy.world to privacy@lemmy.ml on 11 Feb 20:07
https://lemmy.world/post/43021063

Update: I wanna thank everyone for the advice, I’m shipping the bunk phone back for refund today and ive got my eye on a few from swappa and back market for when I get the money to buy.

I’ll probably try out graphene but after looking into crdroid I’m pretty stoked about it having all the customization I’ve been wanting for ages. Which ever feels cleaner to manage and easier for the family to pick up will probably be the go to.

So I fell for the classic blunder and ended up with a pixel that’s not OEM unlocked despite being advertised as such. After a few hours of searching it looks like the only way I’m getting an OEM unlocked pixel is full price from Google itself. I don’t have $400 for a new phone, I bought the one I have for $150 in 2019.

Are there any cheaper ways to get control of my phone?

#privacy

threaded - newest

heiligerbimbam@lemmy.wtf on 11 Feb 20:11 next collapse

Why not buy a used Pixel?

Postmortal_Pop@lemmy.world on 11 Feb 20:57 collapse

That’s what I bought, pixel 7, $150 on amazon but not OEM unlocked. After doing a deep dive on it I’ve found that the only seller on amazon, eBay, and aliexpress that sells one guarantee OEM unlocked is out of stock with no estimated restock. Only other option similar is a refurbished 7a from Google at $350

rb411@lemmy.world on 11 Feb 21:08 next collapse

Return Pixel 7 to Amazon and start looking for used Pixels on Craigslist or FB Marketplace

Ulrich@feddit.org on 11 Feb 21:25 collapse

Or Swappa

SatyrSack@quokk.au on 11 Feb 21:44 collapse

USA only, but Swappa is often recommend online. I see a few here listed as unlocked

https://swappa.com/listings/google-pixel-7

Postmortal_Pop@lemmy.world on 11 Feb 23:17 collapse

I’m looking through swappa and it looks like the unlocked tag is for carriers, how to I verify it’s not going to be a repeat of my current situation?

SatyrSack@quokk.au on 12 Feb 00:41 collapse

The international model is GVU6C, which I believe is the model that is sold directly by Google, which is always unlockable. There are several of those on Swappa.

https://www.phonemore.com/models/google/pixel-7/

floofloof@lemmy.ca on 11 Feb 20:36 next collapse

I’ve found many unlocked, used Pixel phones on eBay. I’ve bought 5 of them this way for myself and my family and had no problems.

Postmortal_Pop@lemmy.world on 11 Feb 21:00 collapse

You mind sending me a link? I could only find 1 eBay seller that stated it was OEM unlocked and they were out of stock.

floofloof@lemmy.ca on 12 Feb 23:08 collapse

I can’t vouch for any particular seller I’m afraid. I used various sellers and I guess I have just been lucky so far.

Jean_le_Flambeur@discuss.tchncs.de on 11 Feb 20:35 next collapse

I bought a refurbished pixel 6a for 200€ from a local store with 2 years guarantee. Using it since 3-4 years and am happy.

Maybe think about a used/refurbished one?

Postmortal_Pop@lemmy.world on 11 Feb 20:59 collapse

That’s what I bought and what I’m looking for, but no one has them with OEM unlocked. The only option I could find that guarantees that is a refurbished pixel 7a from Google for $350

Jean_le_Flambeur@discuss.tchncs.de on 11 Feb 22:05 next collapse

Are you in the EU? Because at my City the first used stuff store i went to had it. But maybe thats different in different markets.

Postmortal_Pop@lemmy.world on 11 Feb 23:09 collapse

Sadly no, rural US. I’d gladly move if I could.

Jean_le_Flambeur@discuss.tchncs.de on 12 Feb 00:02 collapse

:/ HM that sucks. You could go with a phone with lineage OS support, not as secure but at least without bloatware from what I understand.

Or save and try to snipe a good deal on some marketplace

Postmortal_Pop@lemmy.world on 12 Feb 00:12 collapse

I wish I had the time, but after nearly 8 years my charging port is finally giving up. It doesn’t do data transfer anymore and I don’t know how many more times I can plug it in before it stops charging all together.

Jean_le_Flambeur@discuss.tchncs.de on 12 Feb 11:00 collapse

Have you tried to Clean it with a needle? Often its just stuff getting Into the port so the cable doesn’t fit anymore all the way

Postmortal_Pop@lemmy.world on 12 Feb 14:53 collapse

Oh regularly. I’ve been keeping this guy alive for years. The issue looks to be that the port itself is beginning to seperate and the blu g91s isn’t all that repairable.

I’ve been carrying it around long enough that the whole phone has a ~3° warp to it from my jeans holding it too tightly to my thigh. If you sit it glass down on a flat surface it wobbles like a bad table.

blackbrook@mander.xyz on 12 Feb 01:13 collapse

I will bet a lot of the listings you are looking at really are OEM unlocked, they are just not clear about it. I bought a refurbished pixel 7 pro on Amazon in 2023 for $234. The listing just says “service provider: unlocked”. I installed graphene on it.

That said, I see a subsequent review on this listing commissioning that the received phone was not carrier unlocked, so I guess you have to be prepared for some trial and error and returns.

I would broaden your eBay search to just “unlocked” and then maybe message sellers to verify the kind of unlocked state.

Possibly something here is useful: …grapheneos.org/…/13146-any-way-to-tell-if-a-seal…

artyom@piefed.social on 11 Feb 20:43 next collapse

You can buy them from Best Buy? Scamazon? Walmart?

gravitas@pie.gravitywell.xyz on 11 Feb 20:43 next collapse

Not unlockable means you can never have complete control of that device unfortunately. 

You could return the phone to whomever lied about it being oem unlocked. Pixel 6 used is around $150, 7 go for about $220. Use a service like swappa so you have some assurance you will get what you pay for this time.

hexagonwin@lemmy.today on 11 Feb 20:44 next collapse

for some older pixel (pixel 2) there was some sketchy chinese dude that remotely bootloader unlocks the device for USD$30, tho i haven’t tried that myself. most likely using some leaked engineering bootloader binary.

Ignoranceisnotabliss@lemmy.ml on 11 Feb 21:17 next collapse

Buy some old chinashit and flash lineage/cr droid, they actually give you more control than graphene

Postmortal_Pop@lemmy.world on 11 Feb 23:28 next collapse

This is actually the best option I’ve gotten so far, crdroid looks good. Is there anywhere I can find a video that explains the daily use side of it?

BigBolillo@mgtowlemmy.org on 12 Feb 00:20 next collapse

Why not e/os GSI?

exu@feditown.com on 12 Feb 12:39 collapse

That’s basically LineageOS with some pre-configuration for microg

BigBolillo@mgtowlemmy.org on 12 Feb 13:44 collapse

Not exactly it has some interesting customizations like tracker blocking, geo mock and tor included by default. Is a privacy oriented ROM. Not as private as graphene but I believe it’s a good alternative for non-pixel, another one is iodeOS.

LytiaNP@lemmy.today on 12 Feb 00:41 collapse

What about Lineage gives you more control than GOS? I personally have never tried LineageOS since I have a pixel, but curious what it’s like over there.

dx1@lemmy.ml on 12 Feb 05:10 collapse

Graphene is designed to restrict a lot of choices (and root access) to be secure by default, Lineage is designed to give you root control over everything. Very different approaches.

sobchak@programming.dev on 12 Feb 00:13 next collapse

I paid ~$180 for my used mint-condition Pixel 6 on Swappa. You have to look up which exact model numbers are bootloader unlockable, then filter on those.

sic_semper_tyrannis@lemmy.today on 12 Feb 00:34 next collapse

You can find services online that people will unlock your phone for you for a fee

electric_nan@lemmy.ml on 12 Feb 02:35 next collapse

As long as it isn’t “carrier locked”, you should be good to go. The thing about Pixels, is that they allow you to unlock the bootloader (and critically, for Graphene, relock it).

Postmortal_Pop@lemmy.world on 12 Feb 17:52 collapse

You’d think so, but apparently the Verizon model will allow you to unlock the carrier but you can never unlock the bootloader.

electric_nan@lemmy.ml on 12 Feb 18:17 collapse

Damn, you’re right. That sucks.

umbrella@lemmy.ml on 12 Feb 03:31 next collapse

lineageos is a good alternative. but if it’s not oem unlockable, you are out of luck with roms.

Postmortal_Pop@lemmy.world on 12 Feb 04:05 collapse

I’m already returning this one, l was just hoping to find something I could set up that wouldn’t cost most of a check to get my hands on

umbrella@lemmy.ml on 12 Feb 08:50 collapse

almost any phone that can have its bootloader unlocked has lineage available. to make sure it’s well supported, try to find one from their officially supported list.

a lot of cheap motorolas or xiaomis in there.

or an older pixel, might be cheaper and still supported by graphene.

XTL@sopuli.xyz on 12 Feb 07:03 next collapse

The least demanding and least good option is probably universal android debloater, which helps you remove and disable packaged using adb. That’s a bit of control on a device with a locked bootloader.

shiftymccool@piefed.ca on 12 Feb 13:01 next collapse

+1 for Swappa. I get all my devices there, filter by unlocked

Auli@lemmy.ca on 12 Feb 14:32 next collapse

Are there even locked Pixels? Who has them.

relaymoth@sh.itjust.works on 12 Feb 14:35 next collapse

Iirc Verizon doesnt sell Pixels that can unlock the bootloader.

Postmortal_Pop@lemmy.world on 12 Feb 14:48 collapse

Other guy beat me to it, but Verizon has the bootloader so secured no one even bothers trying.

Octagon9561@lemmy.ml on 13 Feb 02:27 collapse

There’s nothing anywhere close to the security and privacy Graphene provides. Find something like a used 8a somewhere. Check Backmarket, Swappa too not just Amazon and ebay.

Postmortal_Pop@lemmy.world on 13 Feb 19:35 collapse

I ended up finding one on backmarket, should be here soon. Hadn’t heard of them or swappa before this thread.

I’m not too invested in the security side of things, it’s just the nice fat cherry on being able to genuinely own my next phone.

Octagon9561@lemmy.ml on 13 Feb 20:01 collapse

Which model did you get?

Postmortal_Pop@lemmy.world on 13 Feb 23:03 collapse

Pixel 7. That was my original goal as it’s the newest that I can afford.

Octagon9561@lemmy.ml on 14 Feb 07:09 collapse

I would have personally opted for an 8a since the 7 will loose support in Oct 2027 while the 8a will keep being supported until May 2031. (In addition to supporting MTE which improves security even more) I haven’t checked their prices on the used market but I don’t think they should be that different.

Postmortal_Pop@lemmy.world on 14 Feb 12:21 collapse

I got the 7 for $140 where the 8a was looking like $200 and that 60 bucks is a big difference. I’m not too worried about the security update issue, my current phone hasn’t gotten a security update since 2024 and I really only use it as a phone. I’m making the change because I’m tired of walking up with new bloatware added once a month and constantly fighting to get Google assistent for control of my settings.